Deconstructing Palestine: A Conversation with Jonathan Kuttab on the Future of Israeli-Palestinian Relations

In an intimate meeting held on July 29, 2024, a diverse group of individuals gathered to engage in a profound conversation on a contentious issue. At the center of this discussion was Jonathan Kuttab, a renowned Palestinian Human Rights attorney and founder of <a href=’Friends”>https://www.fosna.org/’>Friends of Sabeel North America (FOSNA). Our conversation delved into the intricacies of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, the viability of a two-state solution, and the implications of the recent International Court of Justice (ICJ) decision on Israel’s occupation of the Palestinian territories.

Jonathan Kuttab: The Advocate for Palestine

Jonathan Kuttab, a well-respected figure in human rights advocacy, is widely known for his nuanced understanding of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. He is the founder and executive director of FOSNA, a Christian organization that focuses on Palestine but also addresses other causes. Kuttab sends out <a href=’weekly”>https://www.fosna.org/’>weekly email blasts, providing insightful commentary on the ongoing situation.

He has authored several books, including ‘Beyond the Two State Solution’ and ‘The Truth Shall Set You Free’, both of which propose solutions that are non-exclusive. His latest article discusses the <a href=’ICJ”>https://arabcenterdc.org/resource/the-icj-decision-on-israels-occupation-of-the-palestinian-territories/’>ICJ decision on Israel’s occupation of the Palestinian territories. Kuttab believes in nonviolent resistance and acknowledges that Palestinians have the right to armed resistance. However, he insists that ceasefire efforts are only the beginning; justice remains an ongoing pursuit in this conflict.

The ICJ Ruling and its Implications

When asked about the potential impact of the ICJ ruling, Kuttab stated that the decision emphasizes the obligations of all countries to abide by international law. He further noted that the first reactions from the US and Israel were warnings against any unilateral action based on this decision.

Kuttab’s book offers a secular approach to the conflict, questioning the offerings of Zionism and the requirements of Palestinian nationalism. He proposes solutions that are non-exclusive, emphasizing that the state cannot be exclusively Jewish or Palestinian. Kuttab encourages open conversations about his book among readers.

The Path Forward: Dialogue and Non-Exclusivity

Throughout the meeting, it became evident that the path forward is fraught with difficulties but is not impossible. Kuttab emphasized the necessity of giving up the idea of exclusivity and learning to live together. He acknowledged the harsh realities of the current situation but remained hopeful about the future, stating, ‘I don’t think Israel can survive as it is now.’ He called for a path forward that doesn’t involve destruction but liberation.

However, Kuttab also admitted that ‘Oppressors don’t give up their privilege. Internal or external forces take away their privileges.’ This, he suggests, could be a possible vision for the future, but it will undoubtedly be a long struggle.

The Role of International Law and the Future of Nation States

Kuttab expressed doubts about whether international law, as it currently stands, will survive. He warned that if Israel gets its way, the result would be a world where ‘everybody can do whatever they want, which would be horrible.’

He stressed the need for international law to address conflicts, artificial intelligence, pandemics, and climate change. He also criticized Zionism for its attempt to create a Jewish nationalist identity, arguing that it doesn’t align with international order.

The Call to Action

Jonathan Kuttab’s insights are a call to action for everyone involved in seeking justice for Palestinians. He urges us to uphold international law, to continue the struggle for rights, and to reject the idea of exclusivity. Kuttab also supports the Boycott, Divestment, Sanctions (BDS) movement, arguing that Israel’s actions are sustained by international support and that the country cannot survive without external aid.

This conversation with Jonathan Kuttab invites us all to reflect on the complexities of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and to consider the steps we can take toward a more peaceful future.

Freedom Advocacy Network

recent posts

about